“The Star” Review

Original Airdate: September 21, 2023

Written & Storyboarded by: Iggy Craig, Graham Falk, Jacob Winkler & Sonja Von Marensdorff

And we’re back!! Was a bit burnt out by Fionna and Cake but the time I got to the sixth episode review, so I figured instead of forcing myself to muster up the inspiration to get through those last few episodes, I’d take time away to do other stuff and eventually return back. Since then, we’ve also gotten some exciting news – the show has been renewed for a second season! Of course, that means I continue to be trapped in a reality where I’m stuck reviewing Adventure Time episodes for the rest of my life, but hey, at least we’ll get to see more of sexy adult Finn probably!! In all seriousness, I do pretty much plan on continuing this gig as long as I have to drive to do it. I definitely don’t have the same passion as I used to – I started this project about 8 years ago now and I could churn out reviews like crazy, now it takes me weeks to complete just one! But I love AT and it will always have a special place in my heart, so it’s always a treat to get to return to it time and time again. And hey, this blog has actually never had more views! I was shocked to see that last year performed better than it ever did during the show’s original run, which is really, really cool to see. Thank you to all the devoted readers over the years, you are appreciated endlessly!

My gushing aside, let’s get to the real MEAT here. The Star takes us through yet another alternate reality of Ooo, and serves as the unofficial spiritual successor to Stakes. I mean unofficial pretty loosely, because they even brought back the tarot naming conventions with “The Star.” I’m not really a tarot expert or anything, but just scanning over explanations online, I can only assume the reversed meaning most directly correlates with Marcy’s portrayal. On The Tarot Guide, specifically with love in mind, the reverse description reads:

“The Star reversed indicates loneliness and lack of faith in the universe’s plan for you. You may be feeling like you will never meet the right person for you. You may feel that you are becoming cynical about love.”

A large chunk of this is an exploration of Marceline and Bubblegum’s relationship through multiple different iterations, and displaying that, regardless of intent, the passion they share for each other is relatively unchanging. Though Fionna and Cake’s world finds their incarnations in the least toxic of situations, the vampire world features a different type of dependency. Bubblegum has devoted her life to bringing down Marceline and the Vampire King, while Marceline views PB more as a playmate than an actual person. Despite claiming to have zero feelings of affection towards her adversary, PB sure has devoted much of her life around the downfall of said opponent. Even more so than the Vampire King, apparently! Marceline claims that Bubblegum shouldn’t be underestimated, but really, I think she probably could take her out more easily than she lets on. The reason their rivalry spans across so many meetings between the two (enough for Marceline to know that PB’s first name is “Bonnibel”) is because Marcy is restraining herself just a bit in the spirit of fun.

While the Stakes miniseries tackles Marceline’s struggle with feeling as if she can never truly grow as a person, The Star plays with a version of Marceline that never developed out of her childhood worldview. The way she interacts with both PB and the Vampire King prove how infantile her version of connections are, in a way that I don’t think that pain described in the tarot reading is even felt in a conscious way by herself. She only knows how “human” connectedness works from the perspective of a seven-year-old mind, which was likely instantly warped when meeting with the VK. The Vampire King returns once more in this one, with Billy Brown reprising his role. With the amount of tertiary characters that got recasted this season, it’s pretty cool to see they got Brown back, even for such a small role. I do wish he got a biiit more to do, only because Stakes provided us with hints of a really cool character, somewhat squashed it, and then never really did anything with him again. He gets a few neat moments here (namely the scene where VK tries to allure a vulnerable Cake) but is mostly around to drive forward how much Marceline’s motivations have shifted without Simon around.

The episode admittedly has a bit too much fun with Bubblegum and Marceline’s dynamic that it slightly overshadows Simon and Marcy’s connection to each other, but I kind of prefer it that way. There’s a few moments that reinforce how much Simon’s presence had an impact on Marceline’s life, but I didn’t need the whole episode to be devoted around that. We already know that from everything we’ve seen in the series up to this point and it simply serves as an important reminder for Simon when he’s at his lowest, especially considering that he initially figured that Marceline would be fine without him in the flashback shown at the beginning of the season. Although, it was even a bit on-the-nose to have Simon call VK a bad dad, but I like how much of a dork Simon is so I’ll let it pass.

Gary and Marshall continue to be very cute and the entire blood drive event parallel was quite fun. Once again, we’re treated to a lot of different genderbent cameos, this time with a special Jesse Moynihan theme! You’ve got lookalikes of Xergiok, Bandit Princess, Ron James, Magic Man, Maja, Crabbit, Samantha, Tiny Manticore, and even some deep cuts like Gridface Princess, Bella Nocce, and the demon guard. Moynihan’s presence on the show is surely missed, so this is a great little tribute to him (P.S. check out his project Jesus 2 if you haven’t yet!) Along with some other character additions like Eberhardt, Ricardio, and Caroll (did you expect Steve Wolfhard to not bring her back as a genderbent character?) And of course, you have the big reveal of Hunson Abadeer’s counterpart, aptly just as dancey and cruel as her male stand-in. She’s also kind of a baddie! I had to look up who actually voiced her and was surprised to see it’s Erica Luttrell, who portrayed Elise back in Obsidian. A great casting choice, especially since she’s essentially just portraying different versions of Marcy’s mom. Also a nice touch – Tom Kenny voices the male version of Maja, who was portrayed in the original series by his wife, Jilly Talley. Granted, Kenny only has one line of “well!” and I’m sure they just had him do it because he was already in the booth, but I’d imagine at least ONE staff member made the connection.

We’re also treated to some alternate versions of other recurring characters in the vampire world – namely Huntress and Martin. It’s pretty cool how Huntress’s human form is marked only by the lack of there being any source of magic for her with the sun being covered up – though I’d imagine the sun isn’t the only thing that makes her a magic user. It also curious that her name is just “Huntress”; at this point I’m wondering if it’s just a Doctor Princess-esque surname for all of her incarnations. Martin returns once again in a much nobler light. I was kind of wondering what the real purpose was of showing that Martin and baby Finn (who stowed away from baby world) were able to bond together in Martin’s current state. Similar to what I said about Simon and Marcy, we already know that Martin’s capable of showing love under the right circumstances. However, I think this kind of works hand-in-hand with what is being shown between Bubblegum and Marceline: that Martin and Finn have a connection pretty much across all (or most) universes where they coincide. Even in this case, across several universes! It’s interesting to think that such a tumultuous relationship that we’ve come to know is somewhat bound by a strong connections across the multiverse.

We also have the titular alternate reality versions of Bubblegum and Marceline, whose dynamic I’ve spoken heavily about, though not their individual roles. Honestly, while I love how their relationship plays out and parallels the interactions between Marshall and Gary, I don’t love these depictions of the characters that much. I think Bubblegum’s characterization is a little too standard in playing into post-apocalyptic survivalist tropes – it just doesn’t really feel engaging to me when it’s an archetype that I’ve seen across so many different pieces of media, and even then, it’s not an archetype I love in general. I don’t really have a problem with Marceline’s depiction and how it plays into a more childlike version of herself, but I dunno, I don’t really think I like Olivia Olson’s delivery here? It’s a bit too… theatrical? I can’t really articulate what does and doesn’t work for me about the performance, and maybe it’s more so the dialogue that was given to her, but something about it just didn’t jibe with me. Which I know I’m probably gonna get shit for because I’m pretty sure this is the one episode that everyone really got into, but it’s nothing like, awful to me. Like I said, I still really like their dynamic and I do think there’s interesting things to explore with their individual portrayals, namely that Bubblegum still needs to be validated by her own accomplishments and is still vulnerable to deep insecurities beyond her gruff exterior. I just wasn’t swayed by the anime vampire dresses. Sue me!

Oh yeah, and Fionna and Cake are here too! Remember them? I feel bad for anyone that comes to this blog wanting me to whip up paragraphs upon paragraphs of Fionna and Cake’s character journeys, but like, I just don’t have all that much to say! As I’ve mentioned, I don’t think anything with them is especially bad (except for some moments we’ll be exploring in the next episode), but their arcs just kind of speak for themselves and there’s not a ton I feel that is needed to be said that wouldn’t be just reiterating what the episode is showing. You have Fionna feeling guilty in her inability to be able to make a difference through her actions, even when they are out of goodwill, and Cake’s fight for wanting her own autonomy in her new self-sufficient form. It’s all fine stuff, it’s just never something I feel the need to dig deeper into/what I’m particularly drawn to with this season as a whole. Which sounds kind of harsh for a show that’s primarily about them, but I do think each episode comes with its own unique sense of individuality and explores the nature of multiple worlds in a super intriguing way that I don’t really mind that I’m not drawn to them as much! Just be grateful if you’re not a Scarab fan, because I have even less to say about him.

I do mostly dig this one overall, even purely from an aesthetic perspective. It’s got a really great, bleak look to it all, especially in the background department. Which, you think would get less interesting when hopping over the human world, but DAMN, I love the way Hana Abadeer’s stain glass tower looks and really meshes with the gothic tone that the episode is going for. In general, it serves up some very bleak imagery (that the next episode also really excels with) such as vampire world Simon’s lifeless body and, what might be my favorite shot in the entire season, the dead body of Billy with the words “turn back” written on a rock. Quite haunting atmosphere throughout, though I will say, most of the wall writings in this one feel a little lackluster. I live in Philadelphia, so I’m used to seeing super soul-crushing things on bar bathroom walls that could easily rival any graffiti included in a post-apocalyptic landscape. But, as desolate as it feels, the world is also equally as invigorating. The high-adrenaline vampire fight sequences are great, with some really great boarded action, cool Cake transformations, and a solid score to boot. This is probably my favorite of the episodes Amanda Jones scored this season. The track “Vampire World,” which was released as part of the official soundtrack, perfectly captures the frantic energy of the scene it’s in and feels like it encompasses a lot of the spirit of what Tim Kiefer brought to the table in the original series.

The Star is another solid one from the season, and though I don’t think I loved it as much as most people did, there’s no denying that it’s a decent amount of fun. Like the few before it, I really enjoy how it plays with the concept of the multiverse, not showing us entirely different versions of the characters we know, but playing around with what makes them tick across pretty much every realm. I was initially kind of opposed to the idea of having all of these major characters show up throughout the season, because I wanted the franchise to evolve out of needing them to tell stories. But I think exploring these different looks into their lives are insightful not only for themselves as individuals, but for the scope of the world as a whole.

This episode’s little staff tidbit comes from Derek Ballard, who whipped up some concept designs for vampires and Marceline’s second outfit in this episode, which can be seen here. Ballard boarded a few episodes during the run of the original series (Breezy and Nemesis) and also created some of my favorite title cards in the entire show for Betty, Wake Up, Breezy, and Nemesis. It’s great to see another alum back, and even greater that one of his designs did make it into the episode! Sorry I was dissing on the anime dresses earlier!

Favorite line: “How could you bring a child into this world?”

“Destiny” Review

Original Airdate: September 14, 2023

Written & Storyboarded by: Jacob Winkler, Sonja von Marensdorff, Hanna K. Nyström & Anna Syvertsson

One of the promises of Fionna and Cake that I was perhaps the most skeptical about was the incorporation of multiverse elements. The multiverse has become a staple of pop culture in recent years and it’s growing a bit tiresome seeing every genre of content trying to adopt it for storytelling opportunities. It’s easy to see the appeal of the concept, because it does allow for generally limitless storytelling that doesn’t have to be grounded in any sense of logic or reality. But in most examples, it’s utilized for gimmicks more than anything. Even in stuff I like, such as the Spider-Verse movies, it’s a concept that very easily defaults to cameo opportunities from other parts of the franchise or absurdist additions that don’t really add anything outside of being comical. I didn’t want Fionna and Cake to default to hopping from one world to next, visiting a Steven Universe world or meeting a Lego version of Finn. However, it isn’t entirely fair to harp on Adventure Time for necessarily jumping on the bandwagon when the multiverse was apart of its lore far before it became a hot topic – they even beat Rick & Morty to the punch! It’s additionally very reassuring that they incorporate it into Fionna and Cake in a way that feels very meaningful and is actually one of the stronger elements of the season as a whole.

The cold open for Destiny is pretty cool. I like how much Farmworld Finn’s presence is set up in this one. Farmworld prior to the ruling of “The Snowman” felt like an early modern countryside of simple folk that didn’t interact with supernatural elements at all. This beginning paints a similar reality, with the implication that the citizens remained skeptical and on the opposing side of magic, only now it’s evolved into a dystopian, anarchistic landscape. More on that in a bit.

Jumping right into where last episode left off, Simon reveals his plans to help make Fionna and Cake’s world magic again by finding the crown and performing the GOLB ritual once more. It’s clear to see that the events of last episode have put Simon in a state of rejection of his own self, as he seems no longer willing to accept his current place in life. Once again channeling into the themes of addiction, Simon craves his previous life being under the power of the crown, even if it means that he’ll be out of his mind. At least he’ll be numb to whatever pain he’s currently experiencing and won’t have to deal with his issues on a conscious level. Simon justifying using the crown to save Fionna and Cake also isn’t that different from how he used the crown to save Marceline. I have a feeling that, more than just Simon’s own nobility, the power of the crown is tempting enough for Simon that he’s able to make those justifications. Of course, he would never use it if it meant Marceline would be in any real danger, hence him leaving her at the beginning of Everything Stays, but he’s willing to take those chances most of the time because he’s allured to its magic abilities. The same can be said here – with how much he feels purposeless in his own skin, it’s not hard to reel him back in. Even though he knows it’s bad for him and that it will completely change him as a person, it’s a reality he’s willing to accept because at least it will benefit the lives of others. It’s a noble act in theory, but does have a layer of self-centeredness behind it. Simon’s not really thinking about the lives he may hurt if he does start using the crown again, including Marceline, who would end up being left in the dark to a decision being made behind the scenes. Nor is he really thinking about the other lives it would impact in Fionna and Cake’s world, something that Fionna herself is guilty of.

I like all the continued banter between Fionna, Cake and Simon. I mentioned before, but I’m a sucker for all of the cat gags this season has churned out, and Cake bringing Fionna the dead mouse thinking that she loves it is right up my alley. Fionna and Simon’s relationship becomes a lot more fun with Destiny as well. They didn’t really get a ton of time to work off of each other last episode because so much was being thrown at the viewer, so seeing them both work off of each other was nice. I like how she kinda treats Simon like a cringey stepdad that doesn’t understand social cues. Like when he won’t shut the fuck up about Greek mythology at a stranger’s dinner table and Fionna comes back at him with, “dude, what are you talking about?” Simon gets his own bit of sass in though, when Fionna mistakes him for a doctor. He’s an antiquarian, dammit! It’s all fun stuff, and appreciate any time the episode takes to slow it down a bit. There’s some nice moments where Fionna and Cake also banter around at the beginning while looking for loot to steal. The slow pacing of the season up to this point has kind of felt drawn out, but I like that we do get these small moments to breathe in the midst of the ball rolling. Helps it stay with that Adventure Time feel. Oh yeah, also, Scarab’s back again! He does some stuff in this one, but it’s mostly not noteworthy. A bunch of people online were all horned up over his human design, which was fine. He also tinkers around with Prismo’s Time Room and I like the oozing, pink plasma that seems to control synthetic channels to the multiverse. That’s pretty much all I have to say about Scarab in this episode.

The exploration of the Mad Max evolved Farmworld is a blast. I love the designs of the citizens, mostly based on concept art by Michael DeForge, Steve Wolfhard and Delfina Pérez Adán, who previously provided animation work for Distant Lands. I also like all the bits of absurdity sprinkled in; the longshot of the boy on stilts stealing the tire for the car that merges with a much larger vehicle was great, and I like how there’s bits like the chicken man that don’t even make sense in-universe. Like, what got him into this position? Also, this is the first time I’m realizing that the human who notices Cake’s powers is a Farmworld version of Chet! That’s gotta be the most casually sprinkled in cameo of the season. Though, with every episode, I feel like there’s another one that I missed, so we’ll see if I’m still saying that by the end of it. We’re soon reintroduced into The Destiny Gang, whom I was delighted to see again! They really don’t get too much to do that’s funny or interesting and mostly just drive forward the conflict of the episode, though they get a few funny lines in, namely, “he died doing what he loved – trying to ride alligator like horse!”

Most of the episode is more focused on Big Destiny’s kin, introducing us to Little Destiny, who probably has the only design I don’t like out of these gaggle of characters. I dunno, whenever Adventure Time constructs characters using more realistic anatomy and detailed facial features it doesn’t really work a whole lot for me. It kinda reminds me of that lamp from Friends Forever – I think it’s the pronounced lips more than anything. In general, I’m not too captivated by Little Destiny’s role in the episode and her connection to a certain blonde boy, who we’re introduced to shortly after this season’s umpteenth Choose Goose appearance thus far. We’re also treated to a weird little jab from Big Destiny’s other child about wanting to cut Fionna’s nose off, but somebody beating him to the punch. Is this factoring in that dumb theory Pen Ward himself had early on in the series about Ooo’s humans being mutated by having no nose and beaded eyes?? Adam was a pretty vocal critic of this theory back on the commentary of the early seasons, so it might have been a nod to that little debacle. Or even just implying that Farmworld citizens have big ass noses in general.

The aforementioned blonde boy leads our crew to what is believed to be Farmworld Simon, but we get something so much more beautiful: Repressed Adult Farmer Finn™!! This is where my inner fanboy is able to come out and thrive – I LOVE this version of Finn. Going back to my first statement about how the season utilizes the multiverse to the best of its abilities, I like how much ongoing commitment there is to showing that these versions of the main characters essentially are the main characters, just under a different set of circumstances. It’s kind of playing off of what the original series did with Fern, who was just a carbon copy of Finn that was launched in an entirely different direction because of situational experiences. Only this seems to play around with the idea that the nature of our characters is relatively the same throughout each universe, but the nurturing differs almost entirely. Farmworld Finn was given a second chance by Prismo at the end of Crossover, but it’s clear that this wasn’t necessarily a happy ending for him. The impact of the crown left him with psychological scars, as the Finn we see here is far from the almost cluelessly joyful Finn we saw only episodes earlier.

Even outside of a psychological perspective, Farmworld Finn has appears to have chosen (or fallen into) a more traditional path by having lots of children and playing the role of a strong, stoic provider. Lots of people have noted that the 12 or so year time skip would mean that Finn had to have gotten someone pregnant when he was 16 or 17. I don’t think this is that crazy for a world that seems riddled in early modern culture and on top of that, we already know Finn is a horny devil. This is true across every part of the multiverse, especially when he has a dose of trauma under his belt. But yeah, I love his design and all his dialogue is crafted so perfectly. He gets to throw out great antiquated lines like, “I don’t truck with magic,” and, “be gone at first light.” It also can’t be understated how great Jeremy Shada’s performance is – I almost didn’t recognize him at first! Having Shada deepen his voice to sound gruffer is something that could easily feel forced but I think he pulls it off tremendously. He’s old enough at this point that he can channel more baritone inflections without it feeling beyond his scope. When he snaps at Simon for wanting to seek out the crown, the anger in his voice is really felt. And even beyond a speaking role, FW Finn has some really great silent moments where you truly get to experience his life in a nutshell; I love the way he notices how concerned his children are after he lashes out and quickly collects himself to not upset them further, and later when he quietly stares into the fireplace, troubled by the insanity of his past. It’s both a great way to help explore his trauma while also tying back into the delusions that Simon is convincing himself of. Though Ice King probably never brought a level of damage akin to what “The Snowman” did, the impact of the crown and the general madness that it causes is played with a level of absoluteness here, in a way the season would continue to support.

Speaking of Finn’s kids, the names “Jay” and “Bonnie” return after being introduced in Puhoy! This was a nice little detail that may even build on the concept that the Pillow World was, indeed, part of the multiverse. It makes me wonder just how many instances there are in the series where the potential of a wormhole opening is implied – I think Puhoy is a key-in for the most notable example. Farmworld Bonnie is especially cute, which also makes me wonder if there is a Farmworld equivalent to Bubblegum. I like to think that there may not be, or if there is, Finn may have never even crossed paths with her. Finn just named his child that because somewhere in his being he knew he liked that name, which is a concept I think is neat. He also has a gaggle of additional unnamed children, some of which possess features similar to Huntress Wizard’s human forms seen throughout the season (green eyes, red hair). I don’t know how down I am with the continued exploration of Finn and HW’s relationship to the point where she is his soulmate across multiple universes. I liked how the show ended not really focusing on who Finn “ended up” with, because having him settle down at 17 always felt a lil weird. I guess if I really want to tie up the continuity I established with FW Finn getting a girl pregnant at an early age, maybe he met up with her in a similar way to their Ooo counterparts’ meeting in Flute Spell, only they actually consummated it. I guess her role as Finn’s wife is still up in the air because she seemingly passed away in Farmworld, but I think the hints speak for themselves. Even with how much Farmworld Finn has lost, it’s sweet that FW Jake is still kicking. I have no idea how this ancient pooch has lasted so long – it’s possible that Finn got him later on in his childhood as opposed to having him early on, so he’d be around 15 or so now. I think he probably just lives a chill ass countryside life and gets fed well with lots of pets, which is enough to make my god damn heart melt.

Jay is the most prominent of the Mertens family in this episode, and I’m mostly lukewarm on his presence. He’s involved in this star-crossed lovers’ romance with Little Destiny, which I guess adds a level of stakes for the episode? I dunno, I feel like they already had a decent amount of tension going with the fact that they have the Destiny Gang wanting to abolish magic and Scarab after them at the same time. I’m not really sure how their relationship adds to the episode or the season as a whole – I guess they claim their own destiny (no pun intended) in a way that supports what Fionna, Cake, and Simon are also striving for. Still, I don’t find them super engaging as characters and their bits are pretty standard Romeo & Juliet fodder. They even have Cake working off of them by kind of making fun of their whole shtick, but it’s played pretty straight otherwise. Still, it was all worth it to see Farmworld Finn break out a fuckin’ flamethrower arm and set Destiny Gang members on fire. Man does not fuck around! The breakneck pace of the last few minutes are solid: Cake trying to stretch out but still struggling to use her powers is fun; I love Big Destiny’s lashy, perfect eyes when he has his glasses broken; the final confrontation between Scarab and Farmworld Finn is greatly executed, with an impactful curb stomp that had plenty of people questioning whether FW Finn was killed. I don’t really think that’s what they’re going for, but who knows. I feel like the way the rest of the season pans out leaves me believing this probably isn’t the case and it’d be lame as hell if Finn in ANY universe was taken out in such an unceremonious way. This farm boy needs to go down in flames! Also, I didn’t know where else to add this in, but does anyone have any thoughts about Simon mentioning that the crown smells like freshly cut grass? I guess it could just be a throwaway line, but it felt too random to be that. Haven’t seen any theories otherwise, though.

That blabbering aside, I dig Destiny. It works with the multiverse concept to the best of its ability by helping expand the show’s characters beyond just the conditions of Ooo. A looong time ago in my review of Finn the Human, I criticized the episode for not really capturing the spirit of Finn to the best of its abilities, but Destiny makes it pretty clear that… that’s the point. Finn, and all of these characters, are subject to change based on their surrounding environments, leaving us with fragments of the same characters that have their own unique perspective on life. It’s still the soul-shape of Finn in his Farmworld counterpart’s body (that hilariously hushed “math” proves it), but with a lifetime full of different experiences that allowed him to grow in his own unique way. I also enjoy the idea of focusing on one universe per episode as opposed to having them hop from world to world – it allows for the art direction to really thrive when the environment is able to commit to one core theme. And sprinkled in are some solid bits from Simon, Fionna, and Cake, but did you really expect me not to make this entire review centered around Finn at this point? I never claimed to be nonpartisan.

Fionna and Cake brought back a lot of AT veterans for some freelance work, including Charmaine Verhagen! Verhagen co-boarded Wheels and worked on the series as a storyboard revisionist starting around season 8. Verhagen did some concept art for Destiny character designs, but they didn’t end up making it into the actual episode. A shame, because I really like the withered Jakes she whipped up! You can check out her concept art here.

Favorite line: “Now you two should kiss.”